Home » Most Recent Stories

DEEP THOUGHTS FROM RICHARD RUSSELL

28 August 2009 by Cullen Roche 17 Comments

Never a disappointing read – Russell has never lost site of the big picture despite the rapid short-term gyrations in the market.  If you’re not a subscriber of the Dow Theory Newsletters I highly recommend it:

Niall Ferguson, MA, D.Phil., is Laurence A. Tisch Professor of History at Harvard University and William Ziegler Professor of Business Administration at Harvard Business School. He is also a Senior Research Fellow at Jesus College, Oxford University, and a Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University.

I want to include a few paragraphs from a most important article by the brilliant Niall Ferguson, author of “The Ascent of Money, A Financial History of the world.” Ferguson’s article is about the coming “divorce” between the US and China. I believe the future of the world will revolve around the relationship of US and China. The Ferguson article appeared in Newsweek magazine (Aug. 21) and is entitled, “Chimerica Is Headed For Divorce.” And I quote –

“Let’s look at the numbers. China’s holding of US Treasuries rose to $801.5 billion in May, an increase of 5% from the $763.5 billion in April. Call it $40 billion a month. And let’s imagine the Chinese do that every month through this fiscal year. That would be a credit line to the US government of $480 billion. Given that the total US deficit is forecast to be about $2 trillion, that means the Chinese may finance less than a quarter of total Federal-government borrowing — whereas a few years ago they were financing virtually the whole deficit.

“The trouble is that the Chinese clearly feel they have enough US government bonds. Their great anxiety is that the Obama administration’s very lax fiscal policy, plus the Federal Reserve’s policy of quantitative easing (in laymen’s terms, printing money) are going to cause one of two things to happen: the price of US bonds could fall and/or the purchasing power of the dollar could fall. Either way, the Chinese lose. Their current strategy is to shift their purchases to the short end of the yield curve, buying Treasury bills instead of 10-year bonds. But that doesn’t address the currency risk. In a best-selling book titled Currency Wars, Chinese economist Song Hongbing warned that the US has a bad habit of stiffing its creditors by letting the dollar slide. This, he points out, is what happened to the Japanese in the 1980s. First their currency strengthened against the dollar. Then their economy tanked.

“What is China’s alternative if it seeks a divorce from America? Call it the empire option. Instead of continuing in this unhappy marriage, the Chinese can go it alone, counting on their growing economic might (according to Goldman Sachs, China’s GDP could equal that of the US by 2027) to buy them global power in their own right. In some ways, they’ve already begun doing this. Their naval strategy clearly implies a challenge to US hegemony in the Asia-Pacific region. Their investments in African minerals and infrastructure look distinctly imperial too. And now the official line from Prime Minister Wen Jiaobao is to hasten the implementation of our ‘going out’ strategy and combine the utilization of foreign-exchange reserves with the ‘going out’ of our enterprises. That sounds like a Chinese campaign to buy foreign assets — exchanging dodgy dollars for copper mines.”

Russell Comment — I believe the above is a brilliant look at our international future. No nation (the US) can be both the world’s leader and world’s biggest debtor. In his fight to thwart the bear market, Bernanke is sowing the seeds for the future demise of the United States. The law of unintended consequences is about to become operative.

A huge problem ahead is this — will the dollar decline slowly, as it has been doing, or will the dollar crash, setting off a world crisis?

Prediction – Where ever you are now will be your best situation for years to come. The trick ahead will be to hold on to what you have. I’ve been warning that a “hard rain is a’coming.” So far, we’ve only experienced a drizzle.


Great thoughts.

Disclosures - Unless otherwise noted, authors have no positions in any securities mentioned and readers should never consider this to be investment advice. Always consult your financial advisor before acting on any ideas. Comments Guideline - Readers who denigrate authors or other readers will be banned without warning. This site does not tolerate any sort of reader abuse. The goal of this site is to create an environment that is conducive to learning and better understanding of the monetary system and the investment world. We expect readers to behave maturely and responsibly. We welcome and encourage intense and intelligent discourse, but the site adheres to a strict 1 strike policy. While it is your right to speak freely, it is not your right to behave childishly. Above all else, please enjoy the site. It is intended to be used as an educational tool and we hope the intelligent and mature debate will further that purpose. We hope readers will make an effort to respect that goal. Comments with excessive linking or foul language will be moderated before posting.
Comments
  • MS11

    He’s a genius an we are f$cked.

  • Purple Teeth

    I feel ill now.

  • Richard Russell went senile a couple of years ago. Ignore him.

  • Rob

    I would be perfectly happy just holding on to what I have plus a very small REAL return. Bernanke is making that very hard to do in the long-run.

  • AWF

    Thank You –TPC

    Richard Russell has both insight and expierence–ignore his thoughts at your peril

    TPC–you might consider posting the USDollar chart and a little tidbit of analysis.

    The Dollar Trade
    How to position yourself: Long Oil, Long Copper commodities– for those risk averse you can take positions in CVX or Exon (Big Oil) or PCU or FreeportMac G/C
    I am a bit concerned that this is so Obivious

    The Economy trade
    What I see down the road is a cannibalization among the companies trying to get a bigger slice of a “SMALLER PIE” — Throw some Darts–who’s going to win

    The Gold/Fear Trade
    Fear is a Mind killer–Even if GOLD continues to rise which it will–positioning
    in Gold is bad for your psych/ tooo depressing for me!!

    I can not sell short/ Look to Blue Sky and solid Long positions– it will rain soon enough

  • jenny

    I totally agree with his sentiment….that “now is the best situation for years to come, the trick ahead is to hold on to what you have”. I am trying desperately to figure out what that trick is. Holding cash seems dangerous, but investing in risky assets in this environment is full of peril also. In the mean time, I can only fret and read as much as I can to keep tag of where things are going. I’ll be very happy if my investment can maintain it’s purchasing power in the future and not lose it’s value from here on. Money printing is very demoralizing for savers.

  • don

    Seems to me US and China are locked in marriage. Decoupling wrapped around a tanking dollar and rising T. yields is conceptually easy, but I’m not so convinced its going to happen, at least in the medium term. As long as the US maintains its trade deficit and China its surplus we aren’t going to see, for instance, the loss of the US dollar as the reserve currency. Also, any notion that China is gaining on the US militarily, even in the Asia-Pacific, just ain’t true.

  • Sherman McCoy

    While I have great respect for what RR has done, he has too much knowledge to be objective. History doesn’t repeat, it rhymes. Read Stratfor, and you can easily shoot down RR’s analysis. China has no water, a demographic time bomb, and a history of screwing the pooch. The best way to save your fortune is not to short the dollar, but in my humble opinion, short China while the herd still thinks its sexy.

    Does nobody remember 2 decades ago when Japan Inc. was supposed to take over the world? That’s a history lesson that reminds us we should all look further than the end of our nose,. and think more than one step ahead.

  • DH

    Elsewhere, it rhymes. On Wall Street, history repeats…word for word.

  • Hal

    Great perception!
    China’s next target after Africa is the purchase of Australian assets with devalued $US. This process has now begun.
    How does one retain ones personal wealth? Does one buy Australian shares early, before the companies are taken over totally or in part? Or buy tangables, like gold and platinum, real estate, stamps or vintage cars? Or does one sell short and hope the exchanges and banks stay liquid enough to transact your orders?
    Free advice greatfully accepted, payment demands will be met using slightly faded greenbacks!

  • Sherman McCoy

    OK DH, I’ll give you points for pithiness, but with all due respect, tell me, are you comfortable being part of the herd?

    Even if the conventional wisdom is right, that’s not the way you’re supposed to bet.

  • i think mccoy has a good point. china will probably get stronger vis-a-vis the united states over time, but near term their operational leverage to the credit bust is immense. one of the lessons of the 1930s that is rhyming today is that the bust is harder for the home of excess capacity and c/a surpluses than for the home of excess demand and c/a deficits.

    longer term, their demographic problem is severe and will fully manifest by 2040. their baby boom peaked in 1965 and is more severe in its effect than america’s, korea’s or japan’s. past 2020 we might want to consider india.

  • DH

    Thank you for the points. My comment refers to the general behavior of every investor/Wall Street generation, not necessarily to your post. I’m fairly agnostic towards Russell’s remarks.

    The last chapter of Marc Faber’s “Tomorrow’s Gold” paints a more realistic picture of the U.S. and China over the next 20 years. Check out “The Fourth Turning” as well.

  • Matty Gibson

    The problem I have with all the doomsayers on the US dollar is this: against which major currency is it supposed to tank? Which major currency is NOT being devalued by its government printing masses of new quantities of the currency? The English, Chinese, Canadians, Aussies, all of them are running the printing presses. The focus seems always to be on the US dollar, as if QE and bond issues are happening there in isolation.

  • James

    The dollar bearishness is getting to like 2007 levels…It is time to begin buying the USD pretty soon. Maybe not tomorrow, but the USD will surprise everyone again.

  • charlottemom

    McCoy

    China is not Japan and the US that faced Japan is not the same as the US now — economically speaking. US will not China to buy its land and property assets as japan did then. Instead China is, as someone noted, swapping depreciating dollars for land elsewhere. China is ALL OVER Latin America — gobbling up its resources. They are establishing mining companies in South America — they are buying the mountain (many US financials are also busy purchasing land down there, including Goldman of course. But I digress)

    How is the US economy planning to block Chinese ascession? Don’t say alternative energy because that will be impossible if China bans export of rare earth elements (China is the resouce for 98% of these extremely rare metals needed for alternative energy). So what’s our plan for dominance over China?

    The dollar may not crash in the near term, but its trajectory is down, down, down. China has its problems too no doubt so I’m not convinced they are near decouping….yet.

  • leos

    Please give me the remedy now and fast…………………